Reading time: 12 minutes

Partner disputes are a frequent challenge in business management. Whether in an SCI (Société Civile Immobilière), SARL, or SAS, these conflicts often arise from strategic disagreements, financial concerns, or misunderstandings regarding roles and responsibilities.

In this article, we will explore:

  1. Common causes of partner disputes
  2. Legal recourse and alternative dispute resolution
  3. Mediation and arbitration as efficient solutions
  4. Preventative tools: Partnership agreements and contractual clauses
  5. Legal procedures for partner exits or removals
  6. Expert strategies to maintain business harmony
  7. Conclusion

1. Common Causes of Partner Disputes

Understanding the root causes of disputes is crucial for finding an appropriate resolution.

1.1 Strategic Differences in Business Direction

Over time, business partners may develop conflicting visions: one may want to diversify the company’s activities, while the other prefers to focus on consolidating profits.

➡️ Example: In a tech consulting firm, one partner wants to invest in AI-driven solutions, while the other worries about financial risks.

1.2 Unequal Contribution to Business Operations

A lack of clear role definitions can lead to dissatisfaction and resentment.

➡️ Real-life scenario: In an SCI, one partner manages tenant relationships and property maintenance while others remain passive investors.

1.3 Financial Conflicts: Profit Distribution and Capital Contributions

Financial disagreements are a leading cause of disputes, including:

  • Unfair distribution of profits.
  • Disagreements on additional capital contributions for business expansion.

1.4 Decision-Making Deadlocks: Majority and Minority Power Struggles

Power imbalances can escalate tensions:

  • Majority abuse: The majority partner imposes unfavorable decisions on minority partners.
  • Minority obstruction: A minority partner blocks key strategic decisions.

2. Legal Recourse and Alternative Dispute Resolution

Before considering court litigation, businesses should explore alternative dispute resolution methods.

2.1 Open Communication and Internal Conciliation

A direct discussion between partners, possibly facilitated by a neutral advisor, can often defuse tension.

✔️ Best practice: Document any agreements reached to avoid future misunderstandings.

2.2 Mediation by a Professional Third Party

Mediation enables partners to find fair solutions with the help of an impartial mediator.

✔️ Advantages: Faster, cost-effective, and preserves business relationships.
✔️ Example: Two partners in a property investment firm seek mediation to settle disagreements over rental income distribution.

2.3 Arbitration: A Binding and Confidential Process

If the company’s bylaws include an arbitration clause, disputes can be resolved privately without involving courts.

3. Mediation and Arbitration: Effective Alternatives to Litigation

Both options are gaining popularity due to their efficiency in resolving disputes outside of traditional legal proceedings.

3.1 What is Mediation?

Mediation is a structured process where a neutral mediator helps the disputing parties reach an agreement.

➡️ Case study: A family-owned SCI uses mediation to resolve a disagreement over rental property usage.

3.2 Arbitration: A Legally Binding Decision

Unlike mediation, arbitration results in a final decision that must be followed.

4. Preventative Tools: Partnership Agreements and Contractual Clauses

A well-drafted partnership agreement and clearly defined contractual clauses can prevent most disputes.

4.1 Essential Clauses to Include

  • Pre-emption clause: Prevents partners from selling their shares to outsiders without approval.
  • Arbitration clause: Requires partners to use arbitration before filing a lawsuit.
  • Exclusion clause: Enables the removal of a partner in case of serious misconduct.

➡️ Example: A fintech startup includes an exclusion clause to avoid potential conflicts over strategic decisions.

5. Legal Procedures for Partner Exit or Removal

  1. When disputes become irreconcilable, legal measures may be necessary for a partner’s exit.

    5.1 Available Options

    1. Share Transfer: A partner can sell their shares to another partner or an external buyer, subject to contractual agreements.
    2. Buyback by the Company: The business itself may repurchase shares to prevent third-party interference.

    5.2 Company Dissolution

    As a last resort, partners may choose to dissolve the business amicably or through legal proceedings.

6. Expert Strategies to Maintain Business Harmony and Protect Interests

💡 Practical Advice:

  • Consult a business law expert at the first signs of tension.
  • Schedule regular partner meetings to encourage open dialogue.
  • Use tax optimization strategies to prevent financial disputes.

➡️ Related Resource: Read our guide on international tax planning for business owners to safeguard your company’s financial interests.

7. Conclusion

While partner disputes are common, they do not have to lead to business failure. With the right legal tools and dispute resolution strategies, businesses can protect collective interests while maintaining stability.

Need Personalized Guidance? Book a 30-minute consultation
Book My Consultation

Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or tax advice. As each situation is unique, we recommend consulting a professional for personalized advice.